Coles Notes version of our retirement plan
Coles Notes: Student guides to literature, published in Canada. The Coles bookstore first published Coles Notes in 1948. The first title published was on the French novella Colomba by Prosper Mérimée.
Ever since I read David Chilton’s “The Wealthy Barber” coupled with my Dad’s voice saying “pay yourself first son”, I have. Over my entire professional career, I’ve always contributed to RRSPs. Some years were much leaner than others but I always did it. So has my wife. 2011 will be no exception. We feel RRSPs will be a major piece in our retirement puzzle. While we have never had the kind of income to maximize our RRSPs, we do try and optimize them - contribute enough each year to our plans to avoid paying any additional income tax. (We already pay enough tax). To ensure we don’t lag market performance, we’re invested in the market with ETFs:
o Our iShares S&P/TSX 60 Index Fund (XIU) provides us with the relative performance of the S&P/TSX 60 Index, comprised of the 60 largest (by market capitalization) Canadian stocks listed on the TSX.
o Our iShares Dow Jones Canada Select Dividend Index Fund (XDV) provides us with the relative performance of the Dow Jones Canada Select Dividend Index; 30 of the highest yielding, dividend-paying companies in Canada using dividend growth, yield and average payout ratio as criteria.
o Our iShares DEX Universe Bond Index Fund (XBB) provides us with the relative performance of the DEX Universe Bond Index; a broadly diversified set of investment-grade Government of Canada, provincial, corporate and municipal bonds issued domestically – it’s basically our one-stop shop for the bond market.
In my RRSP, I've also got a few U.S. dividend-paying stocks for some international exposure but the majority of our savings are in ETFs.
Many fellow bloggers, such as Canadian Couch Potato, Canadian Capitalist,Michael James on Money, Andrew Hallam and DIY Investor, to name a few are strong advocates of index investing and if you’ve read any of their blogs for any period of time, you’ll understand why. Index investing just makes sense. Our goal over the next 15 years is to steadily increase our ETF units to provide us with a moderate nest egg to compliment the rest of our retirement plan below.
Part B - Dividend Income
Investing in stocks that continually pay dividends or better still, consistently pay and increase their dividends year after year can have a dramatic effect over time – not only does this provide investors with a steady passive income stream but also an increasing passive income stream. Simply put, under this strategy, our money is always working for us so we won’t have to. With every passing month, we’re moving another step closer to our 15-year dividend income goal of $30,000 per year. Aggressive? Yes, very. Unrealistic? I don’t think so. Watch for my next few dividend income updates to find out why I think we're on pace, slowly but surely :)
Part C – Defined Pensions
When I started my job at my current employer, I was offered a choice for my pension plan – defined contribution (DC) or defined benefit (DB). I chose DB since under this structure my pension would resemble a percentage (up to 60% if I wanted to work another 25 years) to the amount I’m earning now. When my wife started her job she was offered the same choice and chose instead the DC plan (based on advice from her Investors Group Financial Advisor). Note: never take advice from Investors Group...just my opinion...
Anyhow, with my defined benefit approach, I know in advance how much pension I will have when I retire. My wife’s pension on the other hand is a little less of a benefit since she is forced to invest in mutual funds our company has chosen and is fully dependent upon the performance of those products. Luckily, we have some indexed products to choose from. While the benefits of a DB plan outweigh those of a DC plan, a DC plan by no means is the end of the world. Overall, we're fortunate to have pension plans. Knowing this, we're going to work these accounts to our utmost advantage. Employer willing, our plan is to continue contributing to each both plans to have about 25 years each of vested retirement benefits when we call it a career.
Part D – TFSAs
Investing in stocks or ETFs that continually pay dividends is one thing, having those securities sheltered from tax forever is something spectacular. At least we can all credit our federal government by doing one thing right over the last few years - establishing Tax Free Savings Accounts! While there remains some fine print to be aware of, TFSAs have many upsides:
o You can open a discount brokerage TFSA to hold stocks or ETFs.
o The funds in the TFSA can be grown and withdrawn tax-free.
o You can contribute to a spousal TFSA and they can withdraw from it tax-free (for income splitting purposes).
Before the government decides to take these accounts away or change them significantly, our goal over the next 15 years is to continue using TFSAs to build tax-free income, using ETFs and REITs for now, but probably Canadian dividend-paying stocks down the line. I'll let you know what and why I buy, when I buy it.
So, there you have it, four parts that when combined will form our retirement plan. I’ve left out income from government benefits such as Old Age Security (OAS), Canada Pension Plan (CPP) and Guaranteed Income Supply (GIS) since while I believe OAS will always exist, CCP might not and I don’t think my wife and I will qualify for GIS. The latter is a good thing since that means everything has gone according to plan.
As the saying goes, I guess time will tell, won't it? :)
What do you think about our retirement plan?
Got some feedback or comments to share?
I hope so, I welcome it.
Cheers!
I’ve written a little bit about my investment strategies in the past and for many months now, I’ve kept two main ones posted on my site. These strategies, dividend investing and indexing, keep me focused however our retirement is more than a two-pronged approach. It seeks to strike a balance amongst four key components you'll read about below.
Just like reading the nuts and bolts about Hamlet in Coles Notes, this post is an overview of our retirement plan.
Part A – RRSPs
Ever since I read David Chilton’s “The Wealthy Barber” coupled with my Dad’s voice saying “pay yourself first son”, I have. Over my entire professional career, I’ve always contributed to RRSPs. Some years were much leaner than others but I always did it. So has my wife. 2011 will be no exception. We feel RRSPs will be a major piece in our retirement puzzle. While we have never had the kind of income to maximize our RRSPs, we do try and optimize them - contribute enough each year to our plans to avoid paying any additional income tax. (We already pay enough tax). To ensure we don’t lag market performance, we’re invested in the market with ETFs:
o Our iShares S&P/TSX 60 Index Fund (XIU) provides us with the relative performance of the S&P/TSX 60 Index, comprised of the 60 largest (by market capitalization) Canadian stocks listed on the TSX.
o Our iShares Dow Jones Canada Select Dividend Index Fund (XDV) provides us with the relative performance of the Dow Jones Canada Select Dividend Index; 30 of the highest yielding, dividend-paying companies in Canada using dividend growth, yield and average payout ratio as criteria.
o Our iShares DEX Universe Bond Index Fund (XBB) provides us with the relative performance of the DEX Universe Bond Index; a broadly diversified set of investment-grade Government of Canada, provincial, corporate and municipal bonds issued domestically – it’s basically our one-stop shop for the bond market.
In my RRSP, I've also got a few U.S. dividend-paying stocks for some international exposure but the majority of our savings are in ETFs.
Many fellow bloggers, such as Canadian Couch Potato, Canadian Capitalist,Michael James on Money, Andrew Hallam and DIY Investor, to name a few are strong advocates of index investing and if you’ve read any of their blogs for any period of time, you’ll understand why. Index investing just makes sense. Our goal over the next 15 years is to steadily increase our ETF units to provide us with a moderate nest egg to compliment the rest of our retirement plan below.
Part B - Dividend Income
Investing in stocks that continually pay dividends or better still, consistently pay and increase their dividends year after year can have a dramatic effect over time – not only does this provide investors with a steady passive income stream but also an increasing passive income stream. Simply put, under this strategy, our money is always working for us so we won’t have to. With every passing month, we’re moving another step closer to our 15-year dividend income goal of $30,000 per year. Aggressive? Yes, very. Unrealistic? I don’t think so. Watch for my next few dividend income updates to find out why I think we're on pace, slowly but surely :)
Part C – Defined Pensions
When I started my job at my current employer, I was offered a choice for my pension plan – defined contribution (DC) or defined benefit (DB). I chose DB since under this structure my pension would resemble a percentage (up to 60% if I wanted to work another 25 years) to the amount I’m earning now. When my wife started her job she was offered the same choice and chose instead the DC plan (based on advice from her Investors Group Financial Advisor). Note: never take advice from Investors Group...just my opinion...
Anyhow, with my defined benefit approach, I know in advance how much pension I will have when I retire. My wife’s pension on the other hand is a little less of a benefit since she is forced to invest in mutual funds our company has chosen and is fully dependent upon the performance of those products. Luckily, we have some indexed products to choose from. While the benefits of a DB plan outweigh those of a DC plan, a DC plan by no means is the end of the world. Overall, we're fortunate to have pension plans. Knowing this, we're going to work these accounts to our utmost advantage. Employer willing, our plan is to continue contributing to each both plans to have about 25 years each of vested retirement benefits when we call it a career.
Part D – TFSAs
Investing in stocks or ETFs that continually pay dividends is one thing, having those securities sheltered from tax forever is something spectacular. At least we can all credit our federal government by doing one thing right over the last few years - establishing Tax Free Savings Accounts! While there remains some fine print to be aware of, TFSAs have many upsides:
o You can open a discount brokerage TFSA to hold stocks or ETFs.
o The funds in the TFSA can be grown and withdrawn tax-free.
o You can contribute to a spousal TFSA and they can withdraw from it tax-free (for income splitting purposes).
Before the government decides to take these accounts away or change them significantly, our goal over the next 15 years is to continue using TFSAs to build tax-free income, using ETFs and REITs for now, but probably Canadian dividend-paying stocks down the line. I'll let you know what and why I buy, when I buy it.
So, there you have it, four parts that when combined will form our retirement plan. I’ve left out income from government benefits such as Old Age Security (OAS), Canada Pension Plan (CPP) and Guaranteed Income Supply (GIS) since while I believe OAS will always exist, CCP might not and I don’t think my wife and I will qualify for GIS. The latter is a good thing since that means everything has gone according to plan.
As the saying goes, I guess time will tell, won't it? :)
What do you think about our retirement plan?
Got some feedback or comments to share?
I hope so, I welcome it.
Cheers!
21 comments:
Great "notes". I think we're doing pretty much the same thing! We both have defined benefits pensions and we work on our TFSAs first, then RRSPs with a focus on indexing and dividends.
We are also looking at some growth investments in the renewable energy sector. These companies don't pay dividends now, but we think 10, 15, 20 years out some of the producers of solar and wind technologies will be making a bundle and we're buying some while they're cheap today (and holding them in our RRSP at the moment).
It's a great plan Mark, you've got a few different baskets to choose from in retirement. So if all of this goes according to plan, I guess the question is at what age do you plan on retiring?
It's funny, but I must repeat... we have exactly same pattern as author . And I believe "I believe OAS will always exist, CCP might not and I don’t think my wife and I will qualify for GIS." lol
The only difference that for bond portion I keep CBO (looks like they give better return and high dividends 4.6%). I need to increase my bond portion and thinking to buy CLF (4.5% ) or XSB (3.35%).
As for equity ETFs, I have XUI and XRE (who has pretty good dividends and IMHO REIT should be good this year)
Very good plan. The only difference for me is that my defined contribution plan is so heavy in mutual funds and safe investments that my own RRSP can be mostly equity. I unfortunately don't even have the option of index investing for our DC plan... So Part A, B and D blend for me in terms of investment holdings.
I have a fifth account to manage too, although unrelated to retirement and it's the RESP. Only have 9 years left ...
@Sustainable PF - thanks! Renewable energy sector is a good place to be, amongst other dividend stalwarts like Canadian banks. You're right about solar and wind, Enbridge is already "going there". I got your comment about TA. They are primarily in coal I know, but moving into other, more sustainable types of energy:
http://www.transalta.com/newsroom/news-releases/2010-10-18/transalta-celebrates-1000-mw-installed-wind-capacity-canada
It will take many years for the transformation to be complete. IMO, coal isn't going anywhere, anytime soon. Until TA stops paying dividends, I'm going to continue owning them.
You don't feel the same?
@Canadian Couch Potato - thanks for your comment Dan. I responded on "My Dividend Investing Strategy" page.
@Echo - our plans is to be out of the workforce for good at 50, another 12 or 13 years.
@Gibor - thanks for commenting! CCP, we'll see eh? Lots can change in another 15 or 20 years! If CPP is there, great, but I'm not counting on it for retirement purposes. That's just me.
CBO is a good product. Good on you to own it.
I'm not a fan of laddered bonds at this stage in my life. Ask me again in another 15 years :)
CLF is more short-term bond, government, no?
If so, pretty much guaranteed 3-4% yield.
I like XIU as well - big fan of that one.
XRE, not so much. I'd rather own the companies outright. I'm working on owning the top-3 holdings.
@PIE - not much we don't agree on eh? :)
It's tough when you don't have the option of indexing with a company plan. I STILL can't believe that IG Financial Advisor recommended my wife (before I met her) pick the defined contribution plan at work. Ugh.
I think you have a fantastic retirement plan. Diversity is extremely important and I think you've mastered that nicely!
As a rather young investor, I don't hold many ETFs right now as my portfolio is a little more aggressive but I am a big fan of the couch potato strategy and that's how I allocated my parents RRSPs.
Right now the only ETF for me is XEG. Needless to say I'm betting on oil haha.
I agree with the other commentators that you have a well structured nicely diversified plan. You're lucky your wife has index funds among her choices. I assume they are low cost.
Excellent article, and right on the money! I think you have this worked out perfectly. Have you maxed out your TFSA's every year? (since you don't pay tax on it when you withdraw - except for the dividend income of course).
@My Own Advisor
CBO it's more short term corporate bonds... I need some bonds as I'm in mid 40's ...
Just bought this morning some CLO (belive in oil and energy) and BMO...
Maybe you are right about XRE,... I also hold CUF.UN, great dividends, but appreciation is not so good...
BTW, found pretty interesting website www.dividend.com (US stocks)... you can register for free for 14 days...then registed again for 14 days with different email lol
@My Own Advisor
For Corporate Bonds I like Mackenzie Sentinel Corporate Bond Fund (MFC756). Yes the MER is high at 1.5% but the yield is currentyl 5.67%. I prefer it to CBO - its performance is excellent. For a mutual fund it has served me very well, I added more two days ago.
@Ninja - wow, high yield indeed! The only bonds I own is XBB (yield = 4%). I hate fees, but I see your point with MFC756 yield like that!
MFC756 has MER 1.65% and this is Asset Class: High Yield Fixed Income . So, you cannot compare it to Short Term CBO. I have similar to MFC756 , TD High Yield Bond with even better YTD growth.
@Cowtown Realist - thanks for stopping by! Thanks also for the complimentary commments - yes, I hope our plan with work out! Couch Potato investing definitely has its merits. XEG, I don't own any but I can see why folks do.
@Gibor - have you checked out dividendinvestor.ca? Great site for research.
@My Own Advisor, yes, sure, I know this website... but it's not free , even there is no free trial.
Yesterday I posted post, but I don't see it here....I'll repeat.
I'm pretty new in dividend investments and I'm just curious. I understand advantages investing into dividend "aristocrats", but their dividend seldom above 5%. On other hand there stocks like ARR, CEL, NLY that offer 11-16% yield and those stocks rated Strong Buy or Buy on different websites. So, why no to buy? OK, they can reduce dividends, but I always can sell. And if I understand correctly, if company declare dividend annually, they cannot reduce them this year?
@Gibor - sorry, I seem to having a few issues with Blogger or vice versa! Those are some high yielding securities you are talking about! You're right, you can always sell (those stocks), I guess I'd rather buy and hold and hold, less transaction fees and headaches. When I get a little more sophisticated and hopefully wealthy, I can have some funds to "play with". Until then, I'm going slow and steady to hopefully win the race.
About your question, if the Board of Directors have already declared a dividend, there's a very, very good chance they will always follow through.
@MOA No problem :)
ARR has 52 weeks range 6.10-8.62 anf 18% yield , ex-div on Feb 11. Looks apealling. :)
I also hold and don't sell , even though it's not so expensive for me I h, I have price 6.95/trade in CIBC and 9.99 in TD...
XMA (ETF materials) doesn't have dividends, but has nice nixure of canadian companies (gold, mining, fertiliser)